Musk’s Twitter Plans Stay Imprecise After First Q and A with Firm Workers
Okay, look, I’ve little question that Elon Musk is a genius on some stage, a visionary who has been in a position to faucet into key funding and improvement alternatives, and make issues occur the place others couldn’t.
I’m not debating this – however his views on social media, and the way social platforms work, more and more appear outdated, misguided, and outright improper in lots of respects.
And as you possibly can think about, workers had many questions – and Musk’s solutions didn’t precisely present a lot assurance of future course for the corporate.
First off, on censorship, which has been a key element of Musk’s Twitter takeover push. Musk has lengthy criticized Twitter’s restrictions on sure speech, and has advocated for extra open communication, within the boundaries of local laws, versus taking up extra officiating on such at a platform stage.
In in the present day’s assembly, Musk reiterated this stance, saying that people ought to be allowed to ‘say fairly outrageous issues’ – although Musk additionally says that such feedback ‘should not be amplified’ by Twitter itself.
What precisely meaning is unclear – although apparently, Musk has usually criticized Twitter’s alleged ‘shadow bans’ which limit the attain of some tweets. It looks as if he’s form of now advocating for this – however how precisely he would envision such course of, in a useful sense, is unclear.
Musk additionally mentioned his plan to fight bots, which has been one other key pillar of his Twitter takeover push.
If our twitter bid succeeds, we are going to defeat the spam bots or die making an attempt!
— Elon Musk (@elonmusk) April 21, 2022
Final month, Musk stated that his Twitter takeover had been successfully put ‘on hold’ because of him primarily not believing Twitter’s knowledge that solely 5% of its lively customers had been pretend/bots. Twitter has since supplied Musk with its ‘full firehose’ of tweets to make an impartial evaluation.
So how does Musk plan to deal with bots?
His resolution could be that customers must pay a specific amount to get their account verified, which might make it too costly to run huge bot networks.
“It must be far more costly to have a troll military.”
That makes some sense, but it surely is also more difficult in observe, whereas moreover limiting the app’s progress prospects, if each consumer has to pay to sign-up. Musk has previously also noted that Twitter ‘will at all times be free for informal customers’, however how these two stances would align is one other hazy component.
Which leads into Musk’s progress plans for the app. As per Musk’s leaked strategy deck, which had been shared with potential traders Musk plans to extend Twitter’s consumer base from the 229 million daily actives it has proper now, to 600 million by 2025, then to 931 million by 2028.
Actually, Musk has advised Twitter workers that his plans are even larger than this, with a goal of a billion users in the app.
Although once more, the element is fairly gentle on right here, with Musk solely offering a imprecise reference to Chinese language messaging apps as a template of types for Twitter progress.
Elon says that if the corporate needs extra individuals to make use of Twitter, they need to mimic the strategy of the tremendous app WeChat in China. “you mainly dwell on WeChat in China….if we will recreate that with Twitter we’ll be a terrific success”
— Alex Heath (@alexeheath) June 16, 2022
Wow, what a stroke of genius that is. This strategy completely hasn’t been tried by virtually each different messaging app, in each different area.
Certainly, Meta has been working on this template for years, first making an attempt to get Western customers extra hooked on Messenger, by way of the addition of a range of expanded functions and tools, then pushing to do the identical with WhatsApp in India and other Asian markets.
It’s by no means labored. For no matter motive, Chinese language customers have adopted messaging apps in a a lot larger method than these in different markets, and whereas Meta continues to be hopeful that it might probably make WhatsApp the important thing connective software on India and Indonesia particularly, the possibilities of US customers growing their reliance on a messaging platform – and undoubtedly on Twitter – are usually not very excessive.
However Elon appears to imagine that he’s the primary to note this, and that that is some hidden gem that nobody has stumbled upon as but, which once more underlines the priority that he’s a bit naïve in his strategy to managing, and maximizing, the platform.
That’s been the identical in his statements about fake accounts and free speech, Elon has a private stance on every of those parts, but it surely’s not just like the questions that he’s elevating haven’t been raised and assessed by each different social app at some stage.
Chronological tweets appear significantly better than what “the algorithm” suggests
— Elon Musk (@elonmusk) May 12, 2022
It nonetheless amazes me that an individual trying to purchase a social media platform doesn’t perceive the affect that algorithmic sorting has on engagement, a key measure of success. Sure, some individuals get aggravated by an algorithm exhibiting them what it thinks they like, however the truth is that every one platforms which have applied algorithmic techniques have seen engagement enhance consequently, together with Twitter itself.
Which leads into the subsequent level raised by Musk:
Elon will get a query on content material moderationn points and what ought to/shouldnt be allowed.
He’s extra fearful about whether or not or not persons are seeing “boring content material,” and that TikTok does a terrific job of protecting individuals entertained.
— rat king (@MikeIsaac) June 16, 2022
Proper, so algorithms are unhealthy, however individuals can’t be proven ‘boring content material’ – and TikTok, which has seen huge success on the again of its extremely attuned personalization algorithm, which fuels its ‘For You’ feed, is a superb instance of what to intention for.
I stay up for seeing how Musk and Co. clear up for this.
Different workers questions associated to variety within the workforce, permitting individuals to proceed working from dwelling (one thing Musk is against) and, after all, potential lay-offs.
Musk has beforehand said that he plans to cut Twitter’s staff base by around 1,000 roles – a seventh of Twitter’s general workforce – over the subsequent two years.
Musk didn’t supply any further assurance on this entrance:
“Proper now prices exceed income. That’s not a terrific scenario.”
Musk additionally – most likely jokingly – prompt that Twitter might add an ‘irony’ label so as to add context to tweets.
Which is fairly silly – however once more, it appeared like a joke. Most likely.
Once more, general, Musk’s responses present a lack of expertise in lots of respects, and a scarcity of a transparent plan as to how Musk expects to make Twitter successful, outdoors of simply getting individuals to tweet extra usually.
Functionally, that’s not one thing you possibly can simply do, and getting extra individuals to tweet has been the complete focus of the app’s workers for the complete 16 years of its existence.
Nonetheless, Musk appears assured that he has the solutions. Like $44 billion assured.
How that interprets into motion, we’ll have to attend and see.